I want to share with you a cake recipe that is so amazingly delicious, so incredibly easy, so personally affirming to those you make it for, that you will (no doubt about it) be making it for the rest of your life. No joke!, not after you make it once.
I’ve been thinking of writing to you about this cake for a while–first because I recently served it to my family (for the gazillionth time), in celebration of my son’s birthday (Ben), but what made me “have” to write about it was after seeing one of my daughters (Jessie), drive off with a hunk of leftover birthday cake to bring to a friend “just because” she knew it would bring this person real pleasure. Now, you might not think bringing a piece of cake to someone is so special…but, this is an “ice cream” cake and I don’t know what it’s like where you live but the traffic lights in my town take so long to turn that, even if this slice of cake arrived in a puddle, Jessie still felt confident the taste would be a special experience. Thus the reason I felt it was so important for you to know about this cake, because it’s so trusted to make people.
Now, wait a minute! Before you reach for your mouse, roll your eyes up and back, and click your way out of here, even people that claim to hate to cook and/or bake can still make this cake! Why?…
BECAUSE THERE IS NO COOKING OR BAKING INVOLVED!! (Well… maybe making the whipped cream, for the topping…but, you could even fudge your way out of doing that part, if you wanted to…I’ll tell you more later).
So, now that (I think) I have your full attention, here’s the step-by-step process of how to make this amazing “Celebration Ice Cream Cake “–in all it’s decadence…And I suggest reading through the entire process so you can understand fully what you will need (the tools and ingredients) to get this done in a way where everything flows. And, if you want to see me making this cake, take a look at the preview of the video here.
And, just to help you trust that there really is something valuable at the end of all of this, here’s a photo of the finished cake (before creating a personalized message on top).

By the way, this entire cake can be assembled weeks ahead and kept in the freezer…
Here is what you’ll need…
Since this is a “three-layer” cake, you’ll need three different types of ice cream (unless, of course, the person you’re celebrating ONLY likes one kind… (regardless, you’ll need 1 1/2 pints of ice cream per each layer, so purchase 6 pints for this cake).
As far as the brand or flavor of ice cream you choose..THIS is where the cake becomes personalized and can really “talk” to the “person of honor” –the one that you’re celebrating. So, pick the special person’s three favorite flavors (If you don’t know, then ask people who know them intimately… it’s fun.)
What you’ll need to separate the ice cream layers…
When purchasing the ice cream for “the person of honor,” also buy their favorite candy and cookies. This is what you’ll crush up and use to separate the ice cream flavors. You’ll need about 1 generous cup of crushed cookies and/or candy per layer…you’ll see what I mean soon).
For the whipped cream topping…
- You’ll need a pint of heavy-whipping cream, (preferably NOT ultra-pasteurized–you can tell by the date on the container. If the expiration date is any longer than 1 1/2 weeks (about 10 days), it’s been heated to retard spoilage. Although the longevity of cream is extended by the ultra-pasteurization process, some of the fresh flavor is sacrificed. It’s not a BIG deal, but if you can get really fresh cream, do it.
- You’ll also need granulated sugar and pure vanilla extract.
- If you don’t want to make the topping, you could use a storebought whipped topping, although–truthfully, since I never use it, I can’t vouch for the flavor or the staying power of the whipped consistency.
For the crust…
You need a 9-inch spring-form pan. (That’s a pan with a bottom disc with a removable sides, that gets tightened into place (or released), simply by flipping a tab. You’ll need a box of chocolate wafer cookies and a stick of unsalted butter.
OK, let’s put this cake together…
To make the crust, take the cookies (the whole box) and pulverize them in the food processor, fitted with the steel blade. Transfer the crumbs to a bowl. Melt a stick of unsalted butter and pour this over the crumbs (yes, use all of the butter). Use a fork to combine the crumbs…(So far, so good?)
Then, just press a thin, even layer of moistened crumbs on the bottom and up the sides of pan. If crumbs fall to the bottom, just pick them back up and remind them who’s in charge (press firmly!).
Once the crust is fully assembled, place on a baking sheet lined with wax paper. Lay a piece of plastic wrap lightly over the top of the pan and stick the pan, on it’s tray, into the freezer.

Here’s a picture of the crust fully assembled, chilled and ready to receive the layered fillings.
The inside of the crust doesn’t need to be beautiful, you just want it to cover the bottom and sides. It’s important to coat the sides well (no holes), since the sides will be visible when you unleash the sides, to un-mold the finished cake.
Then, stick the pan in the freezer for a few minutes, just so the crust becomes cold, which will help the crumbs to stay in place while you assemble the cake. Now, is the right time to take your ice cream out of the freezer, to become softened. Now is also when you should crush your cookies and candies to use in between the layers of ice cream (doing things in this order gives you something “to do” while the ice cream is softening…)

The flavors you see are NOT important...What IS important is that you pick the ones that reflect the preferences of the one you're celebrating. The softening process only takes about 20 minutes (depending on how frozen the ice cream was to begin with). Don't go overboard here, you want to be able to spread the ice cream, not pour it...So, when the crust is cold and the ice cream is spreadable...Here we go!...Plop about 1 1/2 pints (about 3 cups) of softened ice cream into the chilled crust...
Spread the ice cream out into an even layer…

Cover the first layer of ice cream with one of the two types of crushed cookies or candy…

Here are crushed Oreo cookies covering the first layer of ice cream (sometimes I use fudge-covered Oreos) but, again, this is not about me, it’s about YOU or whoever you’re making this cake for.
Now, plop the second flavor of ice cream on top of the crushed cookies…

And spread it out into an even layer…

Ice cream layer number two...
Sprinkle the remaining type of crushed cookie or candy over the ice cream…

Crushed Butterfinger candy bars are covering the second layer of ice cream.
Now (believe it or not), on goes the third type of ice cream…

And it’s spread out on top of the crushed candy…

Ice cream layer number three.
Now, place the cake (on the wax-paper lined tray) back into the freezer so it can firm up. Once firm, lay a sheet of wax paper over the top and let it get frozen solid so it won’t melt while applying the whipped cream topping.

The assembled cake, covered with wax paper (in the freezer).
About the timing: The above process can be done WAY ahead and kept frozen until you want to apply the whipped cream topping (which can be done up to 2 weeks ahead–actually longer, but you want to protect (and preserve) the flavor of the cream…
Here’s how to make the whipped cream topping…
- First, you want to freeze the bowl to your electric mixer, along with the whip attachment. (Of course, you could whip the cream by hand, with a balloon whisk, but I promised you that this cake required almost no muscle to put together, and I meant it). OK, back to the whipped cream.
- Pour 2 cups of very chilled, best-quality heavy cream
- Anyway, put your chilled cream into a chilled bowl and beat it with a chilled whip until it begins to thicken. Add 1/4 cup granulated sugar and 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract (there are many variations of this, but this is the classic way to flavor whipped cream and it’s the way everyone loves it…and it’s the way I make it for this cake (always).
- Continue whipping (over high speed) until the cream forms firm peaks–be careful, here. Once the cream thickens substantially, you can overbeat it (especially if using a high-powered machine). So, it’s best to stop a couple of times toward the end, so you can check the peaks. Once you go to far, you won’t be able to spread it easily on a cake, but don’t throw it out (just keep on whipping until completely broken, to create homemade butter for your morning toast!…) Of course, you’ll need to begin again, to make a topping for the cake.
Here’s what whipped cream should look like when it’s ready…

Perfect whipped cream...firm but still soft enough to swoop.
Now you’re ready to apply the whipped cream topping to the frozen ice cream cake. But first, cover the bowl of whipped cream, stick it in the fridge and set up to use part of the whipped cream for piping on a border, which will happen after you’ve applied a smooth layer to the top of the assembled, frozen cake.
Here’s how to set up to fill a pastry bag …Oh, I didn’t tell you …You’ll need a pastry bag, but nothing fancy. Go to the supermarket and you’ll find a box of disposable bags with a set of four tips. This is perfect. Put the star tip inside of one bag, tip down, so the tip drops down and sticks out of the hole at the bottom of the bag.
Now, take a tall drinking glass and put the bag, tip down, in the glass. Cuff the top two inches or so over the rim of the glass and open the interior of the bag.
Looks like this…

The pastry bag is now ready to receive the whipped cream...
Before you fill the pastry bag, apply the whipped cream to the top of the cake, like this:

Now spread it out in a smooth layer and wipe off the rim.
Fill the pastry bag 2/3 to 3/4 full (while it’s positioned in the glass), then remove the bag, unfold the cuffed portion of the bag so it’s straight, push down the whipped cream and twist the bag shut (so the twisted portion is flush where the whipped cream ends).

- A properly filled pastry bag.
Now pipe a border of whipped cream around the rim of the cake. (You can do this more than once, going in toward the center) re-filling the bag as needed).

Once you’re done with the border, place the cake into the freezer (uncovered) so the topping can firm up.
How to store the leftover whipped cream: Open the pastry bag and put any leftover whipped cream into the bag. Secure the top shut with at twisty. Place the filled pastry bag back into the glass (standing tip down) and stick this in the fridge… So, now you have ready-made whipped cream, to use as you wish…Hot chocolate is a great place to start!
Then, once firm, decorate the border as you wish, using candies and/or miniature cookies. I often use M & Ms (plain or peanut-filled)…

When using a variety of color candy, to have the colors repeat in a uniform order, set up a pattern next to your work surface. That way you can continually refer to it.
Setting this up (like above) helps you to move quickly when wanting to apply colorful decorations in a uniform way (so you don’t melt the topping!). After applying your decorations, freeze the cake (uncovered) until firm, then cover lightly with plastic wrap.
Then, if wanting to write personal, celebratory message on the top of the cake, do so with writing gel (you’ll find it near the disposable pastry bag, in the supermarket). I suggest waiting to write the message until the day of serving. To cover a cake with gel-writing on the top, stick several toothpicks around the cake (around the rim) and loosely cover with plastic wrap. The toothpicks will keep the plastic off the gel. If writing your message on the day of serving, freeze the cake uncovered.
To unmold the cake: Remove the cake from the freezer and place a hot, rung-out kitchen towel around the outside of the spring-form pan (especially on the latch that secures the pan shut). While securing the cake (under the bottom) with your nonworking hand, use your working hand to unlatch the outer rim and ease it off the sides of the cake. Encourage the outer ring to fall down over your nonworking hand, so the cake will now be free of the sides and will be sitting on the bottom disc. Transfer the cake back to the freezer until ready to present, slice and serve.
Let the assembled cake sit out of the freezer, on it’s platter, for 15 to 30 minutes before presenting and slicing. (The timing here will depend largely on the temperature of the room and on how frozen the cake was to start.

Do I really need to tell you how good this tastes?
A Note From Me to You: I’ve personally made this cake countless times for my family and friends, as a way to celebrate them and to convey my love for them. As a result, this cake has taken on a ritualistic quality that’s anticipated, cherished and trusted to bring pleasure to those who are the closest to me. It also has given me a whimsical way to convey interpersonal understanding.
I’d like to share with you something I found laying on the shelf of my freezer, a few weeks before my son’s 27th birthday …

This note (above) was strategically written by Ben and left in the freezer, so I would know his “current” three favorite flavors of ice cream. Although you might think “bummer, now the cake isn’t a surprise”…that’ s not how I felt, at all. To me, this note (in itself) is a cause for celebration because it tells me that he fully understands why I make this cake. That the annual reenactment of this exchange is to purposely celebrate all of my children, individually–in a way that speaks to them personally, by addressing who they are NOW.
The Point: Regardless of the occasion or the age of the person being celebrated, this cake promises to drive the feeling of devotion directly to their core– While everyone else at the table gets to come happily along for the ride! And, if you start now, you can make it a yearly (and beyond delicious) tradition. Trust me, you won’t be sorry.
A reminder: If you want to see me making this cake (with detailed piping instructions), take a look at the preview of the video here. And, for a formally written and printable recipe, click here.
Tags: birthday cake, birthday cake recipe, celebration cake, how to fill a pastry bag, how to make an ice cream cake, how to make the best birthday cake, how to make whipped cream, how to use a springform pan, ice cream cake recipe, whipped cream


























